dancing about architecture

My Aim is True

Posted by: Natalie B. David on: July 1, 2008

“Writing about music is like dancing about architecture. It’s really a stupid thing to want to do.” -Elvis Costello

It may seem strange that this is one of my favorite quotes. I am a music journalist, after all, but I have to say that decision has served me well so far. I love this quote, though, because it reminds me what I love about this job.

To me, music journalism is about more than “writing about music.” It’s about the people behind it and the people it touches. It’s about the stories behind the songs, and the stories that happen because of them.  It’s about how it changes the artist and the listener. It’s about picking the brains of some of the most talented and interesting people in the public eye.

It’s also fucking awesome.

However, even the best critics would be remiss to say that they write exclusively about music (and the best critics probably never would).  In my mind, it is impossible to be a rock scribe and discuss only the sounds. Reviews that only comment on instrumentation and lyrics, without discussing the greater implications for the band, album or listener, would be bland, dull, boring. As Radiohead claims, anyone can play guitar. What’s important is why, how, and what makes any band or album great. It doesn’t always come down to technical skill (in fact, in my experience this is rarely the case).

You don’t have to be the best player or singer to change the entire face of music. Just ask John Lydon,

So I disagree with Elvis Costello in saying.  Writing about music is undoubtedly a challenge—how do you translate sound and feeling into words?—but at its best it says something about people: who the artists are who create it and who we are for loving it. And that is a pursuit well worth the effort.

So welcome to dancing about architecture. Get ready for music, culture and random thoughts.

3 Responses to "My Aim is True"

Nice closing line to this post! I feel like I’ve heard it somewhere before. :)

I thought it was Frank Zappa who coined that phrase. Hmmm. Could have been Costello. I guess it doesn’t really matter. The point is, writing about music is a lot more like writing songs than Costello/Zappa would like to admit. In both instances, writers are trying to capture something ineffable. To me, that isn’t a waste of time at all. Life to me is all about trying to express the inexpressible. And a lot of the time, some great happy accidents come out of the process, where you thought you were headed in one direction and end up somewhere entirely unexpected.

Cheers!
Rob.

Defining the undefinable…trying to put into words the strong emotions generated by music…that is the challenge…and from what I read you do this extermely well. Congratulations…keep up the very good and very interesting work. Thanks

I’ve liked Elvis for a while now, but I never heard that quote before. It’s awesome, though :) I can get that feeling every time I try to write a CD review…

Here’s the only other quote about music journalism I’ve run across:

“Most rock journalism is people who can’t write, interviewing people who can’t talk, for people who can’t read. ”

– Frank Zappa

This quote helps me keep things in perspective :)

Type Writer

Leave a Reply